Contact Us

A Local Card Shop with National Reach

Are you located in the heart of Central New Jersey or Northern New Jersey and asking yourself, "How to sell baseball cards?" or "Where to sell baseball cards?". Look no further, our shop proudly serves collectors from Woodbridge, Edison, Morristown, Millburn, Short Hills, Summit and across North Jersey. Whether you’re searching for the latest Topps, Panini, Upper Deck, or TCG sealed products, we offer one of the most diverse selections in the region — all backed by decades of expertise in the collectibles market.

Modern Sealed Products You Can Trust

From Topps Baseball & Basketball, Panini Football to Upper Deck Hockey and Pokémon, Disney or Magic: The Gathering TCG boxes, we stock the latest hobby releases and fan favorites. Our sealed products are authentic, fresh from distributors, and ideal for collectors, breakers, and investors alike.

• New hobby and retail boxes weekly

• TCG sealed product restocks

• Sports and non-sports cards for all generations

The Nation’s Top Buyer of Vintage and Modern Cards

While we’re proudly local to Central and North NJ, our reputation extends nationwide. We are recognized as one of the nation’s leading buyers of vintage and modern sports cards and non-sports cards, dating from the 2020s back to the 1960s, 1950s — and even back to the early 1900s.

We specialize in:

• Pre-War Baseball Cards (Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Cy Young, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner)

• 1950s–1970s Classics (Jackie Robinson, Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, Hank Aaron)

• 2000s-2020s Modern Rookie cards from all sports. 

• Vintage Non-Sports Sets 1900s - 1960s (Superman, Mars Attacks, Civil War News & other Tobacco and Gum issues)

Our expert appraisers provide honest evaluations and top-of-market offers, whether you’re selling a single card or an entire collection.

We always offer a FREE APPRAISAL for your collection here at the Just Collect site. Just click here:

PSA Grading Submission Services

Want to have your cards graded professionally? We make it simple. Our shop provides PSA & SGC submissions, helping collectors throughout New Jersey and beyond send cards safely and efficiently for professional grading.

Our team will:

• Review and pre-screen your cards before submission

• Handle secure shipping to PSA or SGC

• Track your order and notify you once grading is complete

Whether it’s a vintage Babe Ruth or a modern rookie, we help you maximize your card’s potential and resale value.

Consignment Services with Fanatics Collect

Looking to sell your graded cards for top dollar? We partner directly with Fanatics Collect to offer professional consignment services that reach thousands of active buyers.

We handle:

• Intake and professional imaging

• Market-based pricing strategy

• Secure shipping and sale management

It’s the perfect hands-free way to sell your cards through a trusted national platform.

Why Collectors Choose Just Collect

• 🏆 Trusted for over 20 years in the collectibles hobby

• 📍 Local convenience for New Jersey collectors

• 💸 Nationwide buying power for vintage collections

• 🔍 Professional appraisals and authentication insights

• 📦 Fair and fast payouts — we make selling easy

Visit or Contact Us Today

If you’re looking for a card shop in Central or North New Jersey, stop by Just Collect or contact us to schedule a vintage card appraisal. Whether you want to buy sealed hobby boxes or sell your old baseball cards, we’re here to help you get the most from your collection.

📍 Serving collectors throughout New Jersey and across the U.S.
📞 Call us at (732) 828-2261
🌐 Visit us at www.JustCollect.com

Sign up for our newsletter!

Our FREE newsletter is the best way to keep up on collections we've purchased, shows we'll be at to buy and sell collections, podcasts, cards we have for sale, and so much more! You can sign up for our newsletter by clicking below: